Did you just repaint your home, only to have the HOA claim your color isn’t approved? Maybe you’ve received a fine that came out of nowhere and you’re not sure the HOA even has the right to impose it. In Indianapolis, these scenarios happen more often than many homeowners expect. When you don’t know the rules—or when the HOA doesn’t follow them—disputes can quickly spiral, costing you time, money, and peace of mind.
At Dillman & Owen, our Indianapolis real estate litigation team helps homeowners cut through the confusion, understand their rights under both HOA agreements and Indiana law, and find the best path to resolution. We approach every case with a forward-thinking strategy, combining deep knowledge of real estate law with hands-on litigation experience to protect what matters most—your home, your investment, and your peace of mind.
Understanding HOA Rules and Your Rights
When you purchase a property in an HOA community, you agree to follow its governing documents—often called Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs). These set community standards and help preserve property values, but they do not give the HOA unlimited power. Here’s where to begin:
- Review the Documents – Your CC&Rs and bylaws outline what the HOA can control, what requires approval, and how disputes should be handled.
- Know Indiana Law – State statutes protect homeowners in areas like due process, proper notice, and limits on penalties. If the HOA bypasses these protections, its actions may be unenforceable.
Common HOA Disputes in Indianapolis
Our team has seen just about every type of HOA disagreement, including:
- Architectural or Landscaping Changes – From home additions to exterior paint, disputes often arise when the HOA says changes were made without approval—or approval was unfairly withheld.
- Fines and Fees – Assessments that don’t follow the required process or exceed the HOA’s authority.
- Maintenance Responsibilities – Arguments over whether repairs to common areas, shared walls, or drainage systems fall to the HOA or the homeowner.
How We Help Resolve HOA Conflicts
Our litigation team brings a strategic, layered approach to resolving HOA disputes. We start by identifying whether the HOA followed its own rules and Indiana law, then build a plan that may include:
- Opening Communication – We often find that early, direct dialogue with the board or management can prevent escalation.
- Document Review and Preservation – We gather and analyze meeting notes, letters, emails, and records to identify procedural errors or overreach.
- Negotiation and Mediation – Many disputes can be resolved without a trial, saving you time and cost.
- Courtroom Advocacy – When necessary, our team is fully prepared to litigate, leveraging years of courtroom experience to fight for a fair outcome.
Why Work with Dillman & Owen on Your HOA Dispute?
- Focused Real Estate Litigation Experience – We understand the complexities of property law and HOA governance in Indiana.
- Strategic, Team-Based Approach – Our attorneys collaborate to develop forward-looking solutions that protect you now and in the future.
- Local Knowledge – We know Indianapolis ordinances, zoning regulations, and local mediation programs that can impact your case.
- Client-Centered Advocacy – We take the time to understand your goals and guide you through every decision with clear, practical advice.
Take the First Step Toward Resolving Your HOA Dispute
HOA conflicts can be stressful, but you don’t have to face them alone. At Dillman & Owen, we combine in-depth legal knowledge, negotiation skills, and courtroom experience to help homeowners protect their rights and reach workable solutions, whether through settlement or litigation.
Contact us today to speak with an Indianapolis real estate lawyer who can help you take control of your situation and move toward resolution with confidence.
.png)
.png)
